Saturday, June 16, 2012

Disney's Mulan: Reflection, after 14 years



June 18 marks the 14th anniversary of the release date of Disney's Mulan - and this was actually my favorite classic Disney movie. Although Mulan has been criticized for being an inauthentic depiction of Chinese culture and even of feminism, she did make a popular address to these subjects, albeit for the intended American audience. It's a good story, and it combines (or clashes) values of American and Chinese culture. You could argue that the story is a little mixed-up, or you could argue that the mix of Eastern and Western values makes an interesting interplay as produced by a country that shares American and Asian heritage. (This is even representative in the fact that Mulan also had an impressive cast of Asian-American actors, including Pat Morita, George Takei, B.D. Wong, Ming-Na Wen, and others.)

And so I admit that I'm biased in favor of Mulan, even after 14 years, and with a little more awareness of its criticisms. Still, I can't change the fact that I was touched by the sympathetic story about a girl desperate to prove herself, and that I was inspired by the animation and, yes, the Chinese setting. Nevertheless, it is important to recognize that, as someone put it, Mulan is "an American story in a Chinese context".

American Humor:


If nothing else, you can tell it's an American movie just by the humor. Eddie Murphy does a wonderful job as Mushu - he's very funny - but he's very funny in an African American way, with jokes that Americans would get. Mushu is about as Chinese as Aladdin's Genie is Arab - which is to say not at all. I'm sure his jokes were probably difficult for translators and for foreign audiences, especially Chinese ones. But Mushu wasn't really intended to be a Chinese character other than in the simple fact that he's a little dragon.

Although humor is universal in a few ways, it's actually often very cultural specific, especially if it relies on cultural stereotypes and pop cultural references. And in Mulan there are quite a few "inside jokes" for Americans. When the Emperor's assistant Chi Fu asks for "order" one character shouts "Moo Goo Gai Pan!", a Chinese-American restaurant dish (Incidentally, a Chinese restaurant owner informed me that Moo Goo Gai Pan is the only common dish that translates literally - "Mushrooms and Chicken Slices"). In the movie there are only a few subtle jokes for Chinese speakers - the names of certain characters are puns. Chi Fu apparently means "to bully."

And, for instance, how many non-Americans would catch this reference? Perhaps not even all Americans. But the subtle twist is part of what makes it funny and enjoyable.


Chinese Reception:

Mulan did not perform that well in China at all, and for several reasons. First of all, the Chinese government  deliberately discouraged it from being popularly received, preferring not to market so many foreign movies, among other diplomatic reasons (many people watched pirated versions anyway). In China, Mulan was released in February, after the Chinese New Year, after their holiday movie season. Second of all, even besides the humor, Mulan frankly doesn't translate very well as a Chinese story. Mulan had been criticized by Chinese critics as "too individualistic" (Langfitt).

What Americans might call the value of personal achievement, self-actualization, Chinese might see as "self-aggrandizing". Chinese also value cultivating one's self through discipline, hard work, and ingenuity, but also in keeping with modesty. Mulan admits to proving herself more than helping her family. Inasmuch as Mulan claims to be working for her family, to serve China through the military, she really does things in a kind of Western individualist spirit. She's trying to "fit in" with the other soldiers, but she goes about it in her own way, whether surpassing them or bypassing them.

And, only in a Western movie is it heartwarming to see a great crowd bowing before you for your humble service.

I suspect this looks weird to an Eastern audience..


Chinese Values:

I was impressed, however, with the Eastern notes of filial piety, family honor, and self-discipline. Mulan's family lives with the maternal grandmother, as is traditional and somewhat typical even today for Chinese families in the United States. Furthermore, Mulan is acting for the sake of her family in a more Eastern way, and I think there is a lesson in that for a Western audience. She considers her military service to be for the sake of her father, and that her military achievements are a credit to her family.

As for Mulan's father praying to the ancestors, and their ghostly roles in the movie, I'm not sure prayer is done so literally (ancestors are not "worshipped", but rather honored), but ancestor veneration is also a Chinese value, and one's ancestors may have an influence on your own course of life. In China and Japan it really is not uncommon to have a family shrine dedicated to one's ancestors.

It is true that in Eastern culture, your honor and your shame are reflected upon one's group, whether it's your family, your co-workers, or whoever is considered your team. In Western culture, pride and shame weighs mostly on the individual. As a simple example, in individualist Western thinking, someone losing a contest makes the loser look bad. In collectivist Eastern thinking, someone losing a contest makes his coach look bad. Of course, a Western loser will also feel guilty about his coach and an Eastern loser will also feel bad about himself, but there is a distinctly Eastern sense of collective responsibility. "Losing face" is an expression that arrived in English from a direct translation of Chinese (and Japanese). And, in these cultures, your failure causes your family/supervisor/co-worker/colleague to also lose face.

Sentimental Values: 

Personally, I was struck by the story of a girl trying to prove herself, and to find identity, even if she goes about it in her own way. I do appreciate the feminist themes (which seem to be more closely tied to the feminist movements of the United States - I get the impression that the Chinese legend wasn't intended so much to make a case for female empowerment, but I could be mistaken.), but to me the story is more about wrestling with one's own identity. Mulan doesn't explicitly challenge the patriarchal system because it wasn't her intention. In the beginning of the movie she is trying to present herself as the feminine ideal, and at the end of the movie she forsakes political power and opts to quietly go home. I think Mulan is an empowering female character because she works to prove her ability regardless of how many times she is suppressed. But more importantly, to me Mulan represents the struggle to find our own identity. And now I think that Mulan is also an attempt to reconcile Western and Eastern identities.

In college, when I was studying Japanese, and later failing Japanese, I again thought of Mulan, trying to perform as something beautiful when I was really just pretending. I learned that trying to relate to another culture sometimes makes one feel very self-conscious, and involves its own questions with identity.


Even though Mulan has its contradictions between Chinese and American values, I think it speaks to what Americans do know and do not know of Chinese culture. For Mulan, it seems the makers genuinely wanted to respect Chinese ideals of filial piety, ancestor veneration, honor and shame, and to give credit to Chinese art. Even so, it was a product of Western perspectives. Americans still sometimes present Chinese culture in odd ways, but I think the story of Mulan has its own integrity, and it was made with good intentions. Perhaps Mulan doesn't reach out to China very well, but the film continues to offer introspection into the presence and awareness of China in America.




By the way, the sequel, unfortunately, was made for a much younger and smaller audience, and had much less to do with China.

Sources:

Bancroft, Tony, dir. Mulan. Dir. Barry Cook, Writ. Rita Hsiao, Robert D. San Souci., Perf. Ming-Na Wen, B.D. Wong, Pat Morita, George Takei, and Eddie Murphy. Buena Vista, 1998. Film.

Langfitt, Frank. "Disney Magic 'Fails' Mulan in China." Baltimore Sun [Baltimore] 03/05/1999, n. pag. Web. 16 Jun. 2012.

Morgan, Diane. The Best Guide to Eastern Philosophy and Religion. 1st. New York: Renaissance Books, 2001. Print.

Price, Kathie. "Disney's "Mulan" - A China Parent's Viewpoint." FWCC. Families with Children from China, 06/25/98. Web. 16 Jun 2012.

Gengcheng, Zhao. "Mulan: Powerful and Powerless." US-China Education Trust. n. page. Web. 16 Jun. 2012.

..and Wikipedia.

6 comments:

  1. I'm going to guess you are Asian American with the emphasis on American. It would explain why you aren't so offended by Mulan and why you can defend the criticisms to an extent. Which is a good thing btw. I love Mulan too and I really didn't think about how offensive it was until people here in the states started using the negative stereotypes on a daily basis.

    I just want to point it out since you were off on a few things. For example staying with the maternal grandmother. That is NOT traditional at all. Anything maternal is not traditional at all. But it is modern. After the Chinese Revolution Mao decided to throw out almost everything about traditional China in hopes of making it more progressive. One of those things was the Qing Dynasty version of patriarchy. Now for the common household that didn't really translate to much except that families ended up closer to the mother's side instead of the father's side. Just kinda happened naturally. But back in the setting of Mulan there should be almost zero contact with the maternal family never mind living with the maternal grandmother. A woman who marries is sent to live with the husband and his family. When she has kids they all live in the same household. And Disney didn’t get that wrong. She’s not the maternal grandmother. She’s Mulan’s father’s mother.

    Chi Fu isn't a joke for Chinese audiences. It was probably intended as a joke for Chinese audiences but until I read your article I had no idea any of their names were supposed to be inside jokes. Even if Chinese audiences did I don't think they'd find it funny. Chi Fu was a eunuch. Not only do they not go out to the outposts and supervise the generals they have no authority on military actions at all. They only have power in the king's court and even there they only have any control over a general's actions if the royal family themselves gave those orders. So "bully" doesn't make a lick of sense. And even in the movie Chi Fu was more like a laughing stock than a real bully. He even got bullied a few times if you recall.

    The argument about Chinese audiences not liking it because she was too individualistic is getting taken the wrong way. When I read an article about it back when it first came out in China it read pretty much like 10 stereotypes America can use against Chinese audiences to defend why Mulan didn't do well in China. People don't like her being “too individualistic” in this movie not because Chinese people a. aren't individualistic b. hold onto their "traditional Confucian culture" or c. focus heavily on family values. No the reason is because she's a Chinese figure from the SUI DYNASTY. Think of it like a girl in Victorian England voicing her opinion in front of men or riding full saddle on a horse. It doesn't happen. Mulan's brash and opinionated behavior in the movie wouldn't even be excused if she was Shang or the emperor himself. How she acts comes off as what she is a teenage girl growing up in 20th century America who says what she wants when she wants come hell or high water.

    You can watch any well received Chinese period drama to see how she would really act. Not “not individualistic” and not “traditional” but respectful and well mannered.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Let’s run down some examples. First of all you never not even if you were the crown prince go up to a soldier announcing a draft (in this case a eunuch announcing a draft) and make a public scene by shouting at him to skip over someone. Try that here and you’ll be lucky if you just get maced on the spot. Second you don’t stop a military procession in the middle of their march across the city and again cause a scene. Especially if you are acting alone with no orders from above. What happens to people that run across a normal parade over here? They get arrested. Third even if it did work out for her in the end when she recklessly stole a rocket and ran out into the middle of the battlefield then caused an avalanche it is really unacceptable. I mean that’s just lucky she’s in a movie where she’s the star of the show. Doing any of those things is careless and even in the scene it put all her friends’ lives in danger. She started an avalanche! If this wasn’t Disney all of them would be dead. In fact because the Huns were on horses they’d be able to get out of the way much faster than any of Mulan’s friends.

    “I suspect this looks weird to an Eastern audience..”
    Hardly. Just because the culture teaches you to be humble doesn’t mean people don’t want to be celebrated for their successes. This scene came after she “saved China” so why not show her respect for what she did? She even reacted the right way in this scene not relishing in all of the praise but humbly asking to go home. I think even westerners would be more shocked than full of themselves if people bowed before them after they did something big.

    There’s no reason Mulan in her time period would want to “challenge the patriarchal system.” China was never as patriarchal as the west. We are talking about a dynasty that came before one where women had virtually the same rights and men and when the Empress Wu Zetian came to power. In fact the misogynistic song in the movie doesn’t make sense either. Chinese men aren’t like stereotypical western men who want hot chicks doting on them. They probably would prefer the kind of girl Mulan described. Many well known historical women in Chinese history were girls that “got a brain, who always speaks her mind?”

    I know I’m writing this in 2016 and after 4 years you might have learned about this stuff on your own but maybe somebody else is going to happen on this article and might find this useful too.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Interesting article... May I share an article about the Liu Sanjie show in http://stenote.blogspot.com/2017/12/liu-sanjie-show-at-li-river.html
    Watch the video in youtube https://youtu.be/LGSdvSa0tg0

    ReplyDelete
  4. That’s what i used to be looking for. i am speaking approximately all subjects bundled in this weblog. they all are truly very beneficial for me similarly to for my institution. we are certainly going to use its highlighted records. Buffet in Twin Cities

    ReplyDelete
  5. May i ask if what is the interaction of western and asian values in the movie?

    ReplyDelete